FORT PAYNE, Ala. — A heartbreaking tragedy unfolded Sunday evening, November 9, 2025, when two young lives were lost in a double shooting at the Fort Payne Housing Authority Complex. The devastating incident has left the Fort Payne community in mourning, as authorities continue to investigate the circumstances surrounding the deadly encounter.
At approximately 5:59 p.m., Fort Payne Police received a 911 call reporting gunfire in the 1300 block of Alabama Avenue NW. Responding officers discovered two victims inside the kitchen area of an apartment — both suffering from apparent gunshot wounds. Despite immediate efforts by police and emergency medical personnel, 27-year-old Alisha Nichole Keller and 24-year-old Logan Cordale Brown, both residents of Fort Payne, were pronounced dead at the scene. Their deaths have left family, friends, and neighbors reeling in grief.
Following an urgent preliminary investigation, police quickly identified 27-year-old Jacob Eugene Mitchum, of Oxford, Alabama, as the suspect in the shooting. Working closely with multiple agencies — including the Oxford Police Department, Calhoun County Sheriff’s Office, and the East Metro Area Crime Center (EMACC) — authorities tracked Mitchum as he traveled toward Oxford. He was taken into custody without incident, demonstrating the efficiency and cooperation among law enforcement agencies across jurisdictions.
Mitchum was transported back to Fort Payne, where he was formally charged with Capital Murder and is currently being held without bond at the DeKalb County Detention Center. Fort Payne Police expressed gratitude to the assisting agencies for their coordination and swift action, crediting teamwork for bringing a dangerous suspect into custody so rapidly. Authorities also confirmed that no children were present in the apartment at the time of the shooting, and there had been no prior reports or warnings filed regarding the situation.
In an official statement, the Fort Payne Police Department reaffirmed its commitment to addressing domestic violence and protecting victims. “Domestic violence is a serious crime that affects families and entire communities,” officials said. “Our officers are trained to respond swiftly, investigate thoroughly, and connect victims with resources for safety and support.”
As the investigation continues, officials urge anyone experiencing domestic violence or who may know someone in danger to seek help immediately. Local and national hotlines, including the National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-7233), are available 24/7 to offer confidential assistance. The Fort Payne community now turns to healing, united in grief and determination to prevent future tragedies.
